Philadelphia Vireo at Magee Marsh!
Vireos can be very deceiving, leaving birders without great views to ponder things like how contrasting the facial pattern was or the degree to yellow on the breast. Vireos are very warbler-like in that they can occupy a variety of habitats and use song to attract their mates. Nevertheless, these birds are not warblers and usually will sit still for long periods of time while singing in late spring and early summer. During the Midwest Birding Symposium, I made my target bird for the trip a Philadelphia Vireo. Many had been seen throughout the week, but I was still in Ohio on the last day of my trip without a Philadelphia Vireo. The last day was going to be eventful!
I had already dipped on the first-year male Kirtland's Warbler that had shown up, so I was determined to go home with my original target bird. People had been tipping me off all week that the west-end of the Magee Marsh boardwalk (famous for fall-outs) has hosted a few all week long. I was stationed there on Sunday morning with the intentions of pointing out birds to birders in the area. It didn't take very long before we had upwards of 5 to 6 Philadelphia Vireos swarming above our heads. A sight I had not witnessed in over three years.
I was carrying a Nikon 7x42 EDG binocular and my Nikon D200 and 300mm F4 Nikkor lens with which I took this photo. A few of these guys got close and were extremely social.
Philadelphia Vireos aren't too difficult to ID. In fall plumage, they wash out with a ton of yellow so they really resemble no other Vireo, however, duller birds can be confused with Warbling Vireos if your not too careful. As you will always hear me preach, size and structure are again the first things I look at when trying to ID a Philadelphia Vireo or any species for that matter. Philly Vireo's have a much rounder head shape and very stubby bill in comparison to others. Not to mentioned the shorter tail which makes this Vireo sp. look much stubbier than all the others. Having said all of this, we all know that birds can change their posture and with things like moisture and flight feather wear, birds can trick us all too often. Thus, it is essential to look at multiple attributes before making your final ID.
From a morphological perspective, Philadelphia Vireo's have most of the ventral yellow tones restricted to the upper breast, shown above. No other Vireo has yellow tones that gather on the upper chest. The face pattern is sort of in-between where it is not as strong/prevalent as the Red-eyed Vireo, but not as faded as Warbling Vireo. Philly Vireo's have a pretty distinct gray cap with very dark areas around the eye making the bird looked "Masked." Look for the dark lores and eye-line extending to the base of the bill. Some Vermivora genus warblers like Tennessee are superficially similar, but have straighter, thinner/pointed bills with a short tail. Also, Philadelphia Vireo has a yellow vent and undertail coverts most of the year whereas a Tennessee Warbler has white undertail coverts and vent.
Philadelphia Vireos breed in the boreal forests in Canada as far west as British Colombia, but they take an easterly migrating path and funnel through the Great Lakes region with the most regualrity. This certainly, makes this species hard to find in fall Colorado birding.
So there it is, I got my target bird and it was like seeing a life bird for the first time. Now, I just got to find one of these in Colorado.
I encourage everyone to check out Bill Schmoker's photos of vireos here. He has an nice sample and some Philly Vireos that are much duller then mine. It is a real good comparative to make when learning these birds inside and out.
Good Birding and I hope you finish up fall birding with a bang!








